• Contact
  • About
  • ISSN 3049-9747
  • Authors and editors
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
Sussex Bylines
Advertisement
  • Home
  • Politics
  • Environment
  • News
  • Business
  • Community
  • Sussex
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Politics
  • Environment
  • News
  • Business
  • Community
  • Sussex
No Result
View All Result
Sussex Bylines
Home Politics Democracy

Defenders of Democracy: Zoe Gardner

Zoe Gardner, an expert on migration and the refugee crisis, talks about her work, shrugging off dismissive attacks and delivering on her aims

Ginny Smith by Ginny Smith
08-02-2024 15:31 - Updated on 11-06-2025 08:44
in Democracy, Human rights
Reading Time: 7 mins read
A A
Picture of Zoe Gardner

Zoe Gardner Credit: Zoe Gardner

If you have been following the debate on the UK’s immigration policy and the Rwanda plan, Zoe Gardner’s name is likely to be very familiar to you. Her appearances on the media and her articles in the national press have built her reputation as an expert on migration policies and the global refugee crisis – cemented by her glorious put-down of Conservative right-wing MP Jonathan Gullis when giving evidence to the Bill Committee for the Nationality & Borders Act 2022 in September 2021. A video clip of the exchange recently re-surfaced and went viral on Twitter/X and is well worth watching for Gardner’s calm and informed dissection of Gullis’ dog-whistle arguments. 

Humanity and justice in her DNA

With a father who is a lawyer, Gardner describes human rights as being deep in her DNA, and she spent her early years at university searching for a cause that she could totally commit to. The breakthrough came during a seminar she attended when studying for a Masters in Comparative Politics at the London School of Economics.

“My professor, Eiko Thielemann, an expert on forced migration, described one of the worst things that we do in this country – how we treat refugees.” She went straight from the lecture to sign up as a volunteer with Student Action for Refugees. “And that was it – it became the focus of my entire life.”    

Her experience of working with organisations like Asylum Aid, the European Council on Refugees and Exiles in Brussels, and the Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants has given her a profound insight into the best – and worst – aspects of humanity. Her Twitter/X account carries the motto: “Dehumanisation is not a line, it is a circle” and Gardner explains “the more that you dehumanise some people and see them as ‘other’, the less human you become yourself. It comes back around.”

She mentions the incident of the Greek coastguards who returned men, women and children to their flimsy life rafts and set them adrift in the middle of the Aegean Sea – “They could not have seen these people as humans if they were capable of doing that – but they were also dehumanising themselves.”

Deconstructing Bias

Gardner has an interesting analysis of the contrasting attitudes in the UK towards Ukrainian refugees and those from the Middle East. “There’s an element of racism, of suspicion of people with brown skins and of Muslims.” 

But she also thinks that we are somehow more able to empathise with Ukrainians as people who have full futures and real needs and the right to choose where they end up in Europe. 

“We understand that they may not choose to stop in Poland or in Germany or France and we allow them that choice. Whereas we don’t differentiate between people from Middle Eastern or African countries – we see them as basically all the same, not needing the full spectrum of a human life.” 

She describes the attitude as “of course escape from bombs or famine and get to immediate safety. But you don’t need anything else, and I don’t recognise your legitimate desire for a full life of opportunity and safety as you understand it.”

The Rwanda issue

Inevitably we discuss the government’s latest Rwanda plan. Gardner thinks that the current Conservative administration has taken a scheme that was originally announced by Boris Johnson when he was Prime Minister, but typically with little or no follow-through – and made it a ‘do or die’ issue. 

“Sunak has based his legitimacy on it, which I think is incredibly stupid. He could have abandoned it. I think it is now more likely that a small number of people will be performatively sent there because the government believes that one or two planes taking off might be enough for them to win the election. It won’t stop the boats.”

She is cautious about what might change should Labour win the next General Election. She does credit Stephen Kinnock, Shadow Minister for Immigration, as being genuinely interested in discussing the protection of human rights and she’s pleased that Labour have committed to scrapping the Rwanda Plan. 

“If we just go back to the status quo pre-Covid but maybe are a little bit nicer in how we treat people, the compassionate approach will be seen as a failure, so Labour have to go further.”

A fair and mutually beneficial system

Going further for Gardner means investing in an asylum processing system that is fit for purpose, enabling quick decisions to be made.

“At any given time there are a few thousand people trying to get across the Channel from France who are destitute, and we know that the main nationalities are Iranian, Iraqi, Sudanese and Afghan – people who are most likely to be recognised as refugees. They should be given a travel document to allow them to enter the UK for the purposes of seeking asylum. 

They then enter a well-functioning system that we have control over and at a stroke it would destroy the smuggling gangs. I know that there’s a lot of anxiety about the country being overwhelmed by numbers of refugees, but the numbers are manageable, and they are not going to stop coming.

The key to everything is a system that acknowledges that people will always move and makes the best of that movement to share the many benefits.” 

Facing down attacks with expertise and calm debate

It’s not surprising that given her high profile and her championing of human rights, Gardner attracts a lot of attacks from right-wing trolls on social media. How does she deal with it? She does sometimes get depressed by the sheer level of nastiness, “but then I reach out to other people who are in this fight with me and I do get a lot of support”. 

She also faces the harder-to-combat casual put-down in the media by presenters and other guests. Some have a sexist attitude of “Oh well, she’s here because she’s a pretty young woman, but what she has to say is of no real value”, which Gardner finds incredibly frustrating. 

But then she smiles mischievously – “It does make it all the more fun when they underestimate you. I’ve had Tory MPs who thought that I was the floor assistant and then been very shocked to find that I was the person sitting opposite them on the panel.” 

Hope and resilience amidst the gloom

In these rather gloomy times, what gives her hope for the future? “Really understanding my own field of migration and knowing the challenges and that it’s perfectly possible to fix them – even though it might not be happening right now.” 

She adds, “I believe that it’s my duty to remain hopeful. I don’t have the right to despair – when I’m tempted to, I come back and think – well, what then?  What if we gave up?  What if we weren’t doing what we are doing? It would be so much worse.”

Defenders of Democracy: Neal Lawson
By the same author

CLICK HERE TO DONATE TO OUR CROWDFUNDER

HELP US BECOME STRONGER SO THAT WE CAN CONTINUE TO DELIVER POWERFUL CITIZEN JOURNALISM!

Tags: Racism
Previous Post

Sunak’s solo military march: a democracy in disarray

Next Post

Losing control? The spectre of freeports

Ginny Smith

Ginny Smith

Ginny Smith had a varied career after graduating which included tractor driving, working as an occupational adviser at the University of Sussex and teaching English to secondary school children in Algeria. She now runs her own management development consultancy and is the chair of EUnitySeahaven. She lives in a small village in the South Downs and is passionate about protecting the countryside and environment from inappropriate development. She is a strong supporter of electoral reform and campaigns against the undermining of the UK's democratic institutions. She has an MA in Organisational Behaviour, S1 in General Agriculture from Plumpton College and an all-consuming hobby for a few years was breeding sport horses.   

Related Posts

Iranians protesting with flags
Democracy

Iran’s escalating state violence in the wake of war 

by Maryam Panah
6 November 2026
Brighton University Building
Education

A fair and inclusive class war? Not even Brighton Uni can make that fly

by Ross McNally
5 November 2026
Illustrating the gagging of women's voices in Iran
Human rights

The Iranian women’s voices that will not be silenced

by Maryam Panah
22 October 2026
man sitting on the ground alone
Home affairs

The fear tactics of the far right: the demonisation of lone male migrants

by Maryam Panah
9 October 2026
A prayer stone on a rug.
Human rights

The US war on Iran: the funeral of a 12 year old girl

by Maryam Panah
2 October 2026
Next Post
Container ship ARMIS arriving Malta Freeport 2011

Losing control? The spectre of freeports

PLEASE SUPPORT OUR CROWDFUNDER

BROWSE BY TAGS

Afghanistan Animal welfare Art Autobiography Biodiversity Brighton and Hove Christmas Citizenship Climate change Conflict Cost of living Covid-19 Eastbourne East Sussex Equality Finance Food and drink Football Gaza Gender rights Hastings International Women's Day Lewes Local elections Media Music Nature Newhaven NHS Pollution Refugees Rewilding Schools Sewage Species survival Sport Sunday read Ukraine USA Walking Water Water pollution West Sussex Women youth
Sussex Bylines

We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in Sussex and beyond.

Sussex Bylines is a trading brand of Bylines Networks Limited which is separate to, but allied with, Byline Times.

Learn more about us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Authors and editors
  • Complaints
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Newsletter sign up
  • Letters
  • Network RSS Feeds
  • Network Map
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Download the Bylines Network App

© 2020-2026 Sussex Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9747

No Result
View All Result
  • Politics
    • Democracy
    • Elections
    • Human rights
  • Environment
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health and care
    • Home affairs
    • Transport
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Farming and fishing
    • Planning and housing
    • Science and technology
    • Trade
  • Community
    • Culture
    • History and heritage
    • Lifestyle
    • Sport and leisure
    • Travel and tourism
  • Sussex
  • World
    • Europe
  • Authors and editors

Newsletter sign up

CROWDFUNDER

© 2020-2026 Sussex Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9747